Blog

Dealing With Debt: The Avalanche vs Debt Snowball

By Rubina Ahmed-Haq on April 5, 2018 1 Comment
man typing on laptop

Face it, when it comes to debt, no matter how big or small, it can be a major source of anxiety for Canadians.  Paying debt off is a priority for most people but many worry how they will do it. According to the most recent MNP Consumer Debt Index, Canadians are increasingly worried about their ability to repay their debts. With interest rates rising many are finding themselves struggling financially. The MNP Consumer Debt Index finds, one-third of Canadians now say they are unable to cover their monthly bills and debt repayments. Even more concerning, 48 percent say they are $200 or less from not being able to meet their monthly financial obligations.

If your debt is starting to feel unmanageable, there are a few ways to tackle it to get it paid down as quickly as possible. One is called the debt snowball the other is the avalanche method. Both are highly effective if done right. But both have their own pros and cons.

The Debt Snowball

 The debt snowball works by paying the smallest loan off first and working up to the bigger loans. For example, if a person owns $100 on one credit card and $1000 on the other, they would pay the $100 first and make only minimum payments on their other debt.  The idea is the momentum built from paying a smaller debt off quickly will carry us through to the ultimate goal of being debt free.

The snowball method became popularized by personal finance educator David Ramsay.  On his website he gives these tips to get started:

Step 1: List your debts from smallest to largest.
Step 2: Make minimum payments on all your debts except the smallest.
Step 3: Pay as much as possible on your smallest debt.
Step 4: Repeat until each debt is paid in full.

Pros

According to an analysis done in the Journal of Consumer Research and published in the Harvard Business Review, the snowball method is more effective, because these small wins are a bigger motivator than just paying debt down from most expensive.

Who’s it for?

This debt reduction strategy is great for anyone who gets motivated when they see things getting done rapidly. For example, the debt snowball method may work for someone that always makes a to-do list and feels accomplished when they cross everything off it by the end of the day. It taps into the same emotion we feel finishing that to-do list.

Cons

The major drawback with the debt snowball strategy is you end up making more interest payments than needed.  However, according to Ramsay, the debt snowball works because it is about behavior modification, not math. The debt snowball keeps you motivated to stay on task because you see progress.  There are other debt reduction strategies that will get you debt free sooner with the same amount of money. That’s because the overall interest payments are less.

The Avalanche Method

The classic advice when paying down debt has been to start with the highest interest debt and work your way down while making minimum payments on all your other debt obligations. This is often referred to as the avalanche method. This method works by listing debt from most expensive (highest interest rate) to the least expensive (lowest interest rate.)  In most cases, this means credit card debt is paid first, then followed by a line of credit and then a mortgage. If you also have overdue utility bills that are costing the most, pay those first.

Pros

Your amount of debt is decreasing quickly by tackling what costs the most, rather than how it makes us feel. Your smallest debt is usually the most expensive, like credit card debt, and the largest debt is usually the cheapest, like a mortgage. So, in many cases, it ends up that employing the avalanche method means reaping the benefits of the debt snowball method too.

Cons

It may take longer to see results. Even though it costs less, it may seem like the same number of bills need to be paid, albeit with smaller balances. To stay on top of this, Nerdwallet.com recommends getting organised with a spreadsheet that tracks all the debt, how much interest is being paid and what payments have already been made. This might help keep the momentum going as that one big number comes down quickly.

Keep in mind

Debt repayment for many is overwhelming and getting started can seem impossible. Pick a payment plan that works for you and your personality. When it comes to paying down debt the key is to be consistent and keep up the payments. Most importantly, do not wrack up any more new debt on the side while getting the old debt paid off.

Rubina Ahmed-Haq


Rubina Ahmed-Haq is a Journalist and Personal Finance Expert. She is the go-to money expert in Canada for several media outlets. She regularly appears on CBC Radio, CBC News Network, CTV Your Morning and Global Toronto. She writes for Homes Publishing group, ratesupermarket.ca, debt.ca and has her own website www.alwayssavemoney.ca. Rubina began her career as a broadcast journalist in 1999. Since then she has covered everything from local news, foreign affairs, politics, sports and of course finance! As a business reporter she has worked for CP24 from the Toronto Stock Exchange and reported for BNN. Her work has also appeared in the Toronto Star and various other magazines. She has a Bachelor of Arts degree from York University and is an alumna of the Humber College post graduate journalism program and holds the CSC designation. Her goal is to help Canadians find easy ways to manage their own finances. Follow her on Twitter @alwayssavemoney.

When buying a car, does leasing or financing make the most sense?

By Rubina Ahmed-Haq on April 25, 2019

Buying a car is an expensive proposition. You want to do your research and make sure the vehicle you’re purchasing is best for your needs.  The decisions don’t stop there, though. Once you’ve chosen the car that best suits your lifestyle and budget, you must decide how you’re going to pay for it.  There are…

Start Your Retirement Savings Plan Today

By Rubina Ahmed-Haq on April 23, 2019

The younger you are, the harder it can be to imagine what retirement is going to look like. For some, that major life event is 40 or more years away. The reality is this: the earlier you start retirement savings, the more likely you are to have a successful retirement, one that’s filled with all…

Discover the best budgeting apps for Canadians

By Rubina Ahmed-Haq on April 18, 2019

Technology can be a force for good when it comes to budgeting and saving. Canadians like you who want to spend money wisely can use apps to keep you on track. With the power of budgeting in the palm of your hand, there’s no excuse for being unable to keep your finances in line. Here…

Incremental Budgeting: Gaining Capital Over Time

By Sean on April 16, 2019

Incremental budgeting is a budget type where you add a specific amount of capital to a previous quarter’s or period’s budget to permit slight increases. This method is mostly used as budgeting for businesses. Although this budget method is simple (much simpler than activity-based budgeting), most financial professionals won’t recommend it. The main reason is…

1 Comment Leave a Comment  

Aileen on October 30, 2018 at 2:31 pm

What is the best and fastest way to pay of your debt…

Leave a Comment

Free Savings Estimate

How much do you owe?

$100,000

$5,000
$100,000
Live Chat
Welcome to our Live Chat
Agents are not available at this time. Please leave a message. Thank you.
First Name
Last Name
Phone
Email
Postal Code
Debt Amount
 
PHP Live! powered