When buying a car, does leasing or financing make the most sense?

By Rubina Ahmed-Haq on April 25, 2019 No Comments

Buying a car is an expensive proposition. You want to do your research and make sure the vehicle you’re purchasing is best for your needs.  The decisions don’t stop there, though. Once you’ve chosen the car that best suits your lifestyle and budget, you must decide how you’re going to pay for it.  There are generally two options when shopping for a vehicle: you can finance it or lease it.  There are pros and cons to both options, but first we should explain what each of these terms mean.

Financing a car

When buying a car and financing a car payment, you are amortizing the cost of that car over several months, with an agreed interest rate. Most car loans are usually on five-year terms. If you are borrowing the entire cost of the car and staying on your payment schedule, you will have paid off that loan and own the car outright at the end of five years or 60 months. Some banks offer eight-year car financing options, but for this example we will go with a five-year term. When you own the car entirely, after the warranty expires, you’re responsible for all of the maintenance and repairs. Maintenance costs can be high as the car ages. Car warranties generally last anywhere from three to five years.  

Leasing a car

When you lease a car, you are borrowing the deprecation cost of the term you agree to. During this process, you will hear the term residual value. This is how much the car will be worth at the end of your term. The leaseholder is responsible for making car payments equal to the car’s ticket price, minus the residual value. For example, if you lease a car for three years, you agree to make payments in the amount that the car will depreciate from brand new to when the lease agreement is up. Since cars tend to depreciate quickly in the first few years, you will be making the highest payments the car will ever warrant during that time. Lease rates are often higher than traditional financing as well. So you will be making higher payments on the loan too.

Breakdown of costs when buying a car

Let’s use the example of a person buying a car, in this case a Honda Civic Sedan DX, which is currently priced at $18,517.50.  According to Honda’s payment calculator, the monthly payment for a lease will be $260.65, based on a 48 month term, with a lease rate of 2.99 per cent. By leasing that car, over 48 months you will make $12,511.20 in total payments. At the end you will have the option to buy the car out at its residual value. That is an additional cost of $7510.50. If you do that in the end, the car will cost you $20,021.70.

The same car, if you financed it, would cost you $328.56 a month based on a 60-month term, with a financing rate of 2.49 per cent.  At the end of your 60-month term, the car will cost you $19,713.60.

In the end this car will cost you an extra $308.10 if you lease. That might not seem like a huge difference, but this only works if the objective is to own the car for the long term, meaning 10 or more years.  But if at the end of the term you trade in your leased car for a new one, you will continue to make monthly payments in order to have a car, albeit maintenance free as the car age and extended warranty protects you.

Maintenance costs when buying a car

According to Consumer Reports, “expenses can skyrocket when warranty and free-maintenance periods are over.” They say a Honda by its 10th year of life will cost the owner $455 a month in maintenance on average. Compare that to a newer Honda, less than three years old, that costs $145 a month in maintenance. Using those numbers that same car, even after the term is over will cost you more and more.

More considerations

When buying a car, leasing costs more than financing in the long run, but the difference between leasing and financing may not be as great as many believe. And having a car that is maintenance and worry free has an intrinsic benefit any car owner can attest to.  Lastly, when considering leasing vs financing, calculate how much you drive. Lease agreements often come with a limit on how many kilometres that car can drive annually. If you are driving more than that limit, your only choice would be to go with financing, where there are no rules on how much you drive. 

Rubina Ahmed-Haq

Rubina Ahmed-Haq is a Journalist and Personal Finance Expert. She is the go-to money expert in Canada for several media outlets. She regularly appears on CBC Radio, CBC News Network, CTV Your Morning and Global Toronto. She writes for Homes Publishing group,, and has her own website Rubina began her career as a broadcast journalist in 1999. Since then she has covered everything from local news, foreign affairs, politics, sports and of course finance! As a business reporter she has worked for CP24 from the Toronto Stock Exchange and reported for BNN. Her work has also appeared in the Toronto Star and various other magazines. She has a Bachelor of Arts degree from York University and is an alumna of the Humber College post graduate journalism program and holds the CSC designation. Her goal is to help Canadians find easy ways to manage their own finances. Follow her on Twitter @alwayssavemoney.

The State of Student Debt in Canada

By Steve Horton on June 13, 2019

The average post-secondary student in Canada graduates with $26,000 in student related debt, according to Statistics Canada. This debt is incurred from the cost of tuition, rent, and food. All which have been steadily rising. For young Canadians, cost may be a prohibiting factor from entering post-secondary school. The only solution is to borrow to…

Credit Ratings Explained

By Sean on June 10, 2019

Credit is something many of us take for granted. If you have good credit, you should have no problem borrowing money at the best interest rates with the most favourable terms and conditions. If you’re able to pay for your home, car and other assets in cash, you may not care about your credit score,…

Pay Down Debt with the Avalanche Method

By Steve Horton on May 30, 2019

Paying down debt is among most adults’ main priorities. But sometimes, finding the best method to get your loans under control can be difficult. If you’re dealing with a large amount of debt, just getting started can be overwhelming. If you’re determined to be debt free as quickly as possible, by paying the least interest,…

What is the Snowball Method to Paying Down Debt?

By Steve Horton on May 29, 2019

In a report by the Bank of Canada, called Canada’s Economy and Household Debt: How Big Is the Problem?, it seems the problem is pretty big. Canadian household debt has been rising steadily for about 30 years. At the end of 2018 the Bank says, Canadians owed just over $2 trillion. One third is mortgage…

No Comments Leave a Comment  

Leave a Comment

Free Savings Estimate

How much do you owe?


Live Chat
Welcome to our Live Chat
Agents are not available at this time. Please leave a message. Thank you.
First Name
Last Name
Postal Code
Debt Amount
PHP Live! powered