How To Dispute Debt Collectors and How to Approach Them

By on July 19, 2021 No Comments
Woman on phone disputing her debt

When dealing with a debt collector, it’s easy to feel anxious every time the phone rings. In fact, that stress contributes to debt denial, which might lead someone to simply ignore the phone call (we don’t recommend this). Debt collection agencies collect a variety of unpaid debts, including credit card debt, personal loans, business loans, and more. Once your debt goes to a collections agency, your credit score decreases. 

If you owe money to creditors and you don’t pay that debt, a creditor might hire a debt collection agency to collect the debt. Before the agency contacts you, they’re required to send you a written notice that your creditor transferred the debt. 

The notice should include the:

  • Name of the debt collection agency
  • Amount owed
  • Name of the original creditor, the person or business you owe money to

What if that written notice lists a person that you’ve never owed money to? Or if it lists an amount that’s much higher than what you actually owe? Debt collectors aren’t immune to error. If you notice any inconsistencies, you have every right to dispute the debt collector. 

What to Do If The Debt Isn’t Yours

If you don’t owe money to a creditor identified by the debt collector, there might be an error. Additionally, if the name or company listed on the debt doesn’t match your own, that certainly indicates an error. Here’s what you should do if the debt isn’t yours:

  • Order your credit report
  • Inform the debt collector of the mistake
  • Talk with the creditor to find out how to correct the error

How to Dispute the Debt Amount

If you think you don’t owe the debt outlined in your notice, you have every right to dispute the debt. Or, if you think the principal amount or interest rate is too high, you can dispute that too. 

Here’s what you should do to dispute a debt:

Ask for more information – in writing!

Debt collection agencies must provide a breakdown of the debt if you request more information. Learning more about the debt might shed some light on the amount you owe. You might realize that you don’t need to dispute the debt. Always request proof of the debt and information in writing. 

Evaluate Timing

Most debts disappear from your credit report after 6 years. If a debt collector is calling about debt that’s over 6 years old, it might not even be on your credit report anyway. Consider the timing of the debt collector’s call before deciding to pay or dispute a debt. 

Inform the collection agency and original creditor that you plan to dispute the debt

Make sure you inform them through a medium that gives you proof of notification, such as registered mail, fax, or email. Include any documentation that you think will support your dispute case. However, make sure the documents are copies, not originals. You might not get the documents back. 

Keep track of any communication you have with the debt collection agency and creditor

Keep note of any continuing calls or correspondence that take place after you sent your notice to dispute the debt. Order your phone records, take photos of your incoming calls, and save any emails or letters. Under the Collection and Debt Services Act, a debt collection agency cannot contact you without your consent if you’ve provided notice that you will dispute the debt. You can file a complaint with the Ontario Ministry of Government and Consumer Services if the agency is breaking the law. 

Take it to Court

If you’re unable to dispute the debt and resolve the issue with the agency, consider taking the matter to court. This might entice the agency to offer you a deal; however, you should fight the debt in court if it truly isn’t yours. 

Review Your Consumer Rights

Dealing with debt collectors is stressful. Even worse, some people aren’t aware of their consumer rights when dealing with debt collectors. Make sure you’re aware of your rights to ensure you’re not taken advantage of. Some of those rights state that debt collectors cannot:

  • Share details about your debt with others
  • Contact you at work if you request that they contact you through another medium, either via email or another phone number
  • Charge debt collection fees
  • Initiate legal action against you if the debt has been in arrears for two years or longer


Debt collectors aren’t infallible, so make sure you review any information they share with you regarding debts you owe. Now that you know how to dispute debt collectors and your rights, you have to power to do something about it. Paying your debts as soon as possible helps ease collection calls; however, you shouldn’t pay debts that aren’t yours. If you’re struggling to pay off debt and debt collections agencies keep calling you, consider speaking to a credit counsellor today.

Related to: How to Dispute Debt Collectors


CERB Repayment

CERB Repayment – Why Some recipients Are Being Told They Must Pay The Money Back.

By on July 25, 2022

The dire nature of the pandemic meant that the federal government had to act quickly. They created the Canada Emergency Response Benefit (CERB). This benefit gave financial support to employed and self-employed Canadians affected by COVID-19. CERB benefits helped almost 9 million workers and their families stay afloat. Now, some of these people are receiving…

Awkward Conversations

How to Handle Awkward Conversations About Your Debts

By on July 21, 2022

Talking about the debts you owe is never easy. Regardless of the situation and who it involves, conversations about money are awkward. These conversations, as difficult as they are, are important. To make them easier, it helps to have a plan going into them. Here’s how to start the conversation, and how to ensure it…

Manage Money

How Different Generations Manage Money

By on July 15, 2022

How different generations manage money is an ever-changing topic. From saving to spending, each generation has different money habits. Do you think the way you spend money now is the same way your parents spent money when they were younger? Chances are, it’s not. Have your spending habits changed over time? Chances are, yes. This…

Raw Deal

When a “Good Deal” Turns Out to be A Raw Deal

By on July 7, 2022

A good deal is hard to resist. It’s like winning at retail therapy. Sometimes, good deals are an illusion. How do you know if a ”good deal” is actually a raw deal in disguise? Fortunately, there are some red flags in those red tags that can alert you to potentially higher prices. Anchoring – The…

No Comments Leave a Comment  

Leave a Comment

Free Savings Estimate

How much do you owe?